This is the third rifle I have ordered from Atlanta Cutlery, as always, I paid for Hand Select. I was extremely disappointed in this one. The stock is full of worm holes with several cracks in the stock. The worm holes are so bad, screws will not hold in the wood. The rear sight is some wacko handmade sight and it's not even on straight. Yes, I read other reviews, but the patch box problem is a headache to cut down to size and fit, but it can be done. ALSO, the bayonet has a broken bolster. YES, I paid for Hand Select! If this is Hand Select, I sure would hate to see the others. Sorry AC, but I am displeased with this 3rd purchase.
Another SUPER ONE! Ordered a Hand Select, same as back in 2010. (See my rating review dated 3/26/10 below.) This one is heavy in grease. Will take more time to disassemble and clean. All original brass there, with the exception as expected, of the orig. patch box lid. The new cast one shipped is not even within 1/2" of fitting, toooooo... LARGE. Everything else appears fine with the exception of one logitudinal crack underneath beginning at the front portion of the trigger guard (guard screw)/ below the lock and extends about 12 inches forward of the trigger guard. It appears it will be a easy repair once the stock is cleaned. This will be another great one, when completed cleaning. My first P-37 was missing the flip site....this one has one. I'm happy for that. The bayonet has a slight curve, I would estimate it does not deviate more than 1/8" from true. The brass finger guard that attaches to the ribbed brass grip is loose...will reqire a quick&easy fix. I cleaned the bayonet already to get the serial number, and the blade is fine with very minor pitting in one small area, on one side only. Another lucky pick of the draw..."Select Draw". Thanks again AC! C. GREEN
Product came as described, was completely filthy. I have been working on it now for a month, and I am nearly complete with it. The patch box is too large and would need to be cut down considerably and even then, the hinge mechanism is too large, and the slot for the latch is in the wrong direction. So I have ordered a new patch box from the Rifle Shoppe, and am anticipating its arrival. The bayonet is still a work in progress to get it to fit on the bayonet rail. The three stock retaining pins were in such poor condition that I had to fashion new ones, out of 4"X1" brass blanks. Each one was slightly different and had to be machined individually. Although it is not original, it still looks a lot better, and holds the barrel in place much firmer. The stock had a crack that extended from the third barrel pin to the front of the trigger guard, but this filled nicely with plastic wood. Again a very nice product, just make sure you have a dremel, a bench grinder, and numerous sized flat head screwdrivers.
Got the Rifle in less than a week and spent several days working to get it cleaned up. After the grime was off I found a really nice rifle underneath that needed a little patchwork done on the fore arm and some worming on the butt. The only thing that is an issue is the Grossly over sized patchbox lid that will take a lot of work for fitting. Other than that I am more than happy with my rifle.
Have not started work on it yet but I have over 30 of the rifles from Nepal, I can see this will go well.
Hand-selected speciman -- dirt covered, light rust in barrel, lock full of dried grease, some cracking along top of barrel channel on stock (now repaired), complete except for patch box. Bayonet needs fitting to lug on barrel. Everything cleaned up very well and am very pleased with purchase! I wish someone would reproduce the missing brass patch box for these Brunswick muskets.
The rifles rear site was thre but the flip site was broken off, patch cover missing as expected, all of the other brass was there, actually had about 1" of the original sling still attached to the lower end,the first round of cleaning was already done. The bayonet also was in very good shape, minor pitting, still with a great edge, It will need some fileing to fit the rifle bayonet lug. All I can say is I have a beautiful antique. Thanks AC! C.Green